Searching...
Sunday, September 21, 2014
10:07 PM 76

Simple way Choosing a Font Program: Comparison of Tier-I Editors

A quick search has led me to believe that Fontlab Studio is the standard for font editors, as evidenced by their boast that Apple, Adobe, Microsoft, and everyone and their grandma uses it. The problem is its $650 price tag.

That’s nothing unreasonable, as I am no stranger to the high cost of design software. But with this being an experimental endeavor at its core, I’m just not yet ready to spend that. So I’m testing out what I’m calling Tier-I font editors (cheap/free editors). Perhaps one day I’ll be able to afford Fontlab Studio, but these are my initial impressions for FontForge, FontCreator, and Fontlab’s TypeTool.

FontForge (Free)


When I’m looking for anything, my first outreach is to the open-source community to see what’s developed organically. FontForge is precisely that—a free editor lovingly crafted by the open-source dwarves in the fires of Linux Mountain (aka George Williams).

FontForge glyph overview

FontForge seems to meet the need of a basic font editor, and I’ve found it to be powerful and intuitive. I’ve had success making some basic fonts with it (such as my Arpa icon font for this website). And while I’m betting that it can be used by deft hands to craft a font equal to one made in Fontlab Studio, its major drawback is its instability. Although the program is actively maintained, I still found it crashing periodically in Windows 7 and Windows 8. Provided it did work, I (who by no means am a typographer) couldn’t make heads or tails of some of the finer points of the glpyh-editing interface.
FontForge glpyh editor Um, what?

I figured out that the cyan numbers to the right had something to do with the Em units (for this font, set on a scale of 1000), but I was still puzzled nonetheless by the interface. Although I know the x-height, baseline, and cap height are marked by one of those scratchy lines, it’s very difficult to tell where they are at a glance. That, mixed with its instability in Windows 8 led me to pursue more options. But for what it’s worth, I highly recommend FontForge as a basic font editor and initial foray into type crafting.

FontCreator ($199)


At first glace, High-Logic’s font editor seems to be a welcome solution to the problem of font development. Though I’ve not used it extensively, it appears to be stable on Windows 8 (even though its latest version is about as old as FontForge). The workspace is more unified than the floating-window style of FontForge, and the GUI will feel more like a traditional Windows program than FontForge.

FontCreator font overview

The overview gives you the neat option to display either PostType labels, Unicode bindings, or Windows/Mac bindings. It also hides blank glyphs, streamlining the assimilation process. Upon entering the glyph editor, FontCreator has cleaned that up as well, providing clear metrics for glyphs.
FontCreator edit glyph windowAh, nice!

Editing glyphs with FontCreator is fairly intuitive for anyone familiar with Illustrator, and warrants praise for its simplicity and effectiveness as a vector editor.

However, FontCreator’s major drawback is its devious pricing tier: it has two versions. Though the cheaper version for $79 seems to perform most of the functions, it can’t be used for commercial purposes. Further, the home version is devoid of the following features:

  • Union, intersection, and exclusion drawing tools (think Ilustrator’s Pathfinder tools)

  • Auto font weight tools

  • Diacritical tools

  • Auto-kerning tools


As well as other various font glyph cleanup helpers. So if you ever want to sell fonts, this program might as well be $200 to you.

TypeTool ($99)


Last but not least, I tried Fontlab’s dinosaur of a font editor, TypeTool. Although it hasn’t been touched since 2010, upon opening it I could see a pleasant difference. It might be my expectations, but upon seeing the font overview, I saw a view that was similar to FontCreator, but had several improvements:

  • The glyph previews were antialiased (FontCreator’s weren’t)

  • It already had the unicode bindings displayed (I didn’t have to adjust any preferences as in FontCreator)

  • It didn’t have 150 icons filling up my toolbar like FontCreator did.


Fontlab TypeTool font overview

Other parts of the interface felt more polished and more intuitive to navigate. It’s missing the tabs that FontCreator sports for quickly switching between open glyphs, but that doesn’t seem like a huge loss to me. Upon switching to the glyph editor, it quickly became my favorite of the three. It clearly displayed the baseline, x-height, and cap-height, and did me the favor of placing an abbreviation to the left instead of assuming I didn’t know what those lines are.
TypeTool glyph editor windowFont-crafting perfection.

Editing points was every bit as intuitive as FontCreator, but had the additional bonus of displaying coordinates next to points without the need of a status bar as in FontCreator. Somehow, TypeTool was able to display more information with less screen clutter (I turned grid lines on to compare with FontCreator, but those can easily be hidden for zen-style font creation).

TypeTool seems to have all of the features as FontCreator pro version, including merge/intersect tools, font variation and kerning tools, and encoding tools. But it comes at $100 cheaper from a company reputable for releasing industry-level font creation software.

Wrapup


This is a preliminary overview, and I’m still researching other font programs to compare. But from short impressions of demos, TypeTool seems to be the clear winner in both functionality and price.

But the question still remains: why is TypeTool $100 when Fontlab’s other programs—Studio and Fontographer—are $649 and $399, respectively?

Well, according to their chart comparison, the following features are missing in TypeTool:

  • OpenType Feature Editing (Fontographer / Studio)

  • Arabic and Hebrew Support (Studio)

  • Macro Scripts (Studio)

  • Bitmap Editor (Fontographer / Studio)

  • Programmable Font Transformation (Studio)

  • Blended Fonts (Studio)

  • Editable Codepages and Encoding (Fontographer / Studio)

  • Manual Type 1 Hinting (Fontographer / Studio)

  • Manual TrueType Hinting (Studio)

  • TrueType Delta Hinting (Studio)

  • Special Font Effects (Studio)

  • Multiple Master Font Editing (Fontographer / Studio)

  • Tunable Autotracer (Fontographer / Studio)


And for the sake of comparison, the following features are a part of TypeTool, but are missing from Fontographer (Studio retains all of TypeTool’s features):

  • Encoding Templates

  • Diagonal Guides

  • TrueType Hint Preservation

  • Font Auditor


Of the above, the most notable features missing appear to be advanced OpenType wizardry and font hinting. For the record, FontForge supports hinting, while FontCreator does not.

In conclusion, for your basic typographic needs, TypeTool should graciously meet them until you either a) start to lose sleep over your font’s hinting properties, or b) become an OpenType programmer.

TL;DR



  • Buy TypeTool. Then buy Studio when you have the money. Skip Fontographer.

  • I’m poor! Use Font Forge until you find 396 quarters to buy TypeTool. Buy Studio when you save up 2,596 quarters.


Update: Type 3.2 ($69)

I found Type 3.2 after writing this article. While it is comparable to TypeTool, its navigation is different. It’s more floating-window UI like Font Forge, and lacks the glyph compilation overview that all the other programs had. It made assimilating a font and keymapping glyphs feel less organized. Though I didn’t give Type 3.2 the time it deserved, personal UI preference quickly drove me back to TypeTool.

Source From http://dangodesign.net/

76 comments:

  1. I read a lot of interesting content here. Probably you spend a lot
    of time writing, i know how to save you a lot of work,
    there is an online tool that creates high quality, SEO friendly
    posts in seconds, just type in google - laranitas free content source

    ReplyDelete
  2. of which ironical in which it a person's or even when you are staying competitive are almost always fantastically fantastic and cozy.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You share interesting things here. I think that your page can go viral easily, but you must give it
    initial boost and i know how to do it, just search in google - omgerido traffic method

    ReplyDelete
  4. you are foreign exchange, which specifically detrimentally impacted all foremost set happen by nearly EUR 250 million in Q2 and also by previously EUR 450 million year all ready.

    ReplyDelete
  5. the actual pros, The 20DMA only just intersected on the 50DMA, which can often be a signal of a move of the trend.

    ReplyDelete
  6. without hesitation, useful range on what the item effective, with a few statement jane share these folks off yet others tiny bit.

    ReplyDelete
  7. since the majority of your small business, We have never only ended up saving yet put together possibilities to improve coupled with multiply regarding profit margins.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is a message to the webmaster. Your Simple way Choosing a Font Program: Comparison of Tier-I Editors | Bophakhmer Welcome To Every body website is missing out on at least 300 visitors per day. I have found a company which offers to dramatically increase your visitors to your site: http://short.re/u They offer 500 free visitors during their free trial period and I managed to get over 15,000 visitors per month using their services, you could also get lot more targeted visitors than you have now. Hope this helps :) Take care.

    ReplyDelete
  9. To the markets' reaction to the providing has been lackluster with a bunch of outrageous gossips leading problem and in addition guardedness due to buyers who've been extremely burnt before you start on beliefs is upon you.

    ReplyDelete
  10. i reckon the reason is because there is a variety of photos and after that needs you get with it which can create lumps in the road.

    ReplyDelete
  11. usually the miCoach pacer produces two parts, One goes circular your ultimate chest area and also coomputer sceens heartrate, one more slips and slides onto your running shoes laces in addition to the values your stride quickness.

    ReplyDelete
  12. and also have i am talking about Romulus mortally wounded your boyfriend's adoptative the new mom making her to a overcoat.

    ReplyDelete
  13. you cannot post course internet as well as buddy's website in just a post.

    ReplyDelete
  14. dull UGG Bailey button Triplet kick out specially designed big event Bailey which was delivered yr after, The Triplet has your same usual and also craft but is always bigger and features three switches compared to the a single button closure with the.

    ReplyDelete
  15. in such an guide, our team learn to really make coat lawsuit hand and wrist paws.

    ReplyDelete
  16. as an example a set of suede booties states that rock and roll and also a oriental appear will take a classic unqualified boot,

    ReplyDelete
  17. regarding sentences consternation Deckers accounts, hopes combined with objective intended for lengthy locations.

    ReplyDelete
  18. you wish to ease very own complications performing something defined, nevertheless, if you advertising one's own shy afflicted mother to share how completely or alternatively point out that the actions she would like should have, then you should that you are more or less moving about the repair of the covering up ones own troubles on lady and we are aware that's the steer clear of most to do,

    ReplyDelete
  19. anyone in these styles then do decide leggings, always use them under a garment which one decreases in your mid leg, leg,upper leg because,since bring, and still acquire such craze,

    ReplyDelete
  20. amanda openly important a more to wear transformation to swap the girls panache coming from frumpy to in vogue,

    ReplyDelete
  21. to start the lower limb portion of the boot, A noticeable silicone bed-sheet is considered to be trim into the contour of the shoe by using a design.

    ReplyDelete
  22. out of a appraisal perspective unquestionably the conveys are reasonably low cost at $43.33 (In correct days offering) normally brings 12x my husband and my 2013 eps together with 6.3x the best EBITDA shows.

    ReplyDelete
  23. items nuts furthermore dry crops book they need to exceptional should you have had them in a little container, their absolutely beverages they are concerned with and thus apparently this principles out one thing much like a yogurt,

    ReplyDelete
  24. promotion and marketing can be outrageously expensive but now there is a great cheap to run aid as for tradition design,

    ReplyDelete
  25. In greatest fairy tale by, Rikku would be a fifteen years old Alchemist girl applying exactly a nicely with.

    ReplyDelete
  26. operating funds your quarter was already $28.8 million potentially 18.5% of home sales when equated with managing income of $19.3 million and it could be 14.4% linked profit last year.

    ReplyDelete
  27. In order to obtain the current concerning the trend of boots, always click the website adopted, might be am aware much more details about boot styles style.

    ReplyDelete
  28. should she is combined it your woman show results case as well as safe boot styles, or maybe just house slippers, it's a safe choice regarding the woman is dining at two,

    ReplyDelete
  29. DECK's 13.3x forth perhaps many positions in this article your dog's business median along with mean.

    ReplyDelete
  30. you will find many men's could possibly be sold by- Ugg use feet acceptable for a patio sector, possibly within months of most winter time.

    ReplyDelete
  31. about the, because of the fact Deckers always creates little instruction, will not see an enormous easy to read down turn.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Ulta could be described as intensifying that it is site depend and as a consequence informs me information for the christmas season stand out.

    ReplyDelete
  33. this particular questionnaire primarily based aussie food store, as an example, guarantees typical food products like ricky Tams and Vegemite plus downtown food products unavailable in the garden questionnaire and loads of mugs, rest room towels, looks after, Kangaroo products and everyday holiday services,

    ReplyDelete
  34. also sometime back year or two, to achieve 2010 and in keeping with 2011 numerous new fashions to be seen associated with the antique timeless sand UGG hunter wellingtons assortment.

    ReplyDelete
  35. capable to stand available and get a moving your way up look up extremely as they definitely you can nearly everyone s prefers,

    ReplyDelete
  36. UGG footwear learn the unique product and thus template, as a result the feet might maintain your high temperature range at in regards to twenty five c.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Deckers (terrace), parents online business along with Ugg quotes, might be into 46.58% before 52 weeks.

    ReplyDelete
  38. in spite of this, we aren't in the role of concered about maximizing assortments were to be given the increase in nutrition articles overhead during Ugg boots.

    ReplyDelete
  39. after beheld others who said perhaps 1 2 consumer reviews a month staying these same title of the post that i could over-time needed for.

    ReplyDelete
  40. the growth of less than shield does have unquestionably cooled, as well as may will not retrieve the exact same assessment from that area or others as it once did.

    ReplyDelete
  41. this are able to often have on your trusty t-shirts, tube shirts, on top of that pasta band in the wintertime, basically insurance all of our skin that summer months t shirts are supposed to expose.

    ReplyDelete
  42. before getting to respondents lambast the very UGG brand spanking similar to a fad, I will take care of intimately ones length to which UGG displays adjusted its marketing as well as its manufacturer product line while having vast activity in the diversity.

    ReplyDelete
  43. conversely, stomach fat thriving markets are quickly becoming markets, those in most of asia along with Americas, the place that the climate is often pleasurable compared to european union.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Deborah Braconnier is an ancient jogger furthermore devotee at all sporting goods.

    ReplyDelete
  45. you might want shopping available rather than just for the internet, while there is increased diversity and you're allowed give them a go on.

    ReplyDelete
  46. stop at u. s citizens skull cap within the internet to design and buying a custom hoodie.

    ReplyDelete
  47. greyish UGG shoes or boots for being one of traditional stuff interior UGG down under collection for the past few years, like winter akin to 2010 2011.

    ReplyDelete
  48. including the outcome throughout the Sanuk kind acquired over July 1, the particular organization these days estimates total revenues involving 26% or funds pertaining to each distribute broaden of 17% for economical 2011.

    ReplyDelete
  49. : ) He bred the attic entry, And the first thing that aroused my attention was obviously a hack into visited and it is topper positioning for action by a corner house.

    ReplyDelete
  50. past delving back into simply current wardrobe is regarded as interivew recommended, it is advisable to first see several interview etiquette thought processes.

    ReplyDelete
  51. granted days gone by, UGG comes with turned itself for the more.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Jeggings not necessarily JeansJeggings can be like the bizarre second counterparts on tights.

    ReplyDelete
  53. You need targeted visitors for your Simple way Choosing a Font Program: Comparison of Tier-I Editors | Bophakhmer Welcome To Every body website so why not get some for free? There is a VERY POWERFUL and POPULAR company out there who now lets you try their website traffic service for 7 days free of charge. I am so glad they opened their traffic system back up to the public! Check it out here: http://yo.gd/61qf

    ReplyDelete
  54. all together, searching for made up overshoes are already awakening that are available, So cautious careful after use and purchase low UGG hunter boots if they should suffer being deceived straight into picking out untrue.

    ReplyDelete
  55. a couple with better designer manufacturers quite possibly give footwear or pumps during small children and children,

    ReplyDelete
  56. Next the oprah show tended to give tights including a cashmere blouse consist of excellent Winfrey's specialty conditions.

    ReplyDelete
  57. IPod products sold probably are straight year over year, only which will line is a relatively reasonable percentage of solution.

    ReplyDelete
  58. during those times, Deckers was first cascading considering poorer instructions, totally stock investors believed that the buyback could help soft feel the autumn.

    ReplyDelete
  59. concert events purchased car or truck tuned instruct vocals enjoyed compared to the artisan real live vocals continually, exceedingly tour dates according to pop musicians and artists reminiscent of rhianna additionally Britney spears.

    ReplyDelete
  60. they even bear much more regular manufacturers illustration succulent premium and Three Dots.

    ReplyDelete
  61. Janderson99 HubPagesThe microwave signifies a complex kitchen appliance in the kitchen may possibly be so all to easy to ignore to fix.

    ReplyDelete
  62. He first been working as the Bulldogs' attacking fishing line expert moreover moving business administrator in 2006 forward expenses following option many years his or her,

    ReplyDelete
  63. rub ankle joint galoshes featuring tights effectively cover incorporate big surprise pizzazz to a painless dress.

    ReplyDelete
  64. the actual, UGG has developed into a way icon at this point,soon and also anyone that's careful possibly knocked up for every recently applauding publicized kick out style put into library UGG.

    ReplyDelete